Items are limited and may not be available in all stores. If you're making your decision based on nutritional content alone, it's basically a toss-up, withAldiReviewerstating that both butters have 100 calories per serving, 11 grams of fat, and 30 milligrams of cholesterol. Finding the best butter was no joke for our Test Kitchen! Aldi Irish butter spreads and tastes a lot like Kerrygold, and it even has a slightly lower sodium content. Irish butter is advertised as softer than American butter, and on that front the Countryside Creamery Irish butter doesnt disappoint. Its awesome Im still getting updates on this subject since 09/19. And our testers could taste the difference. This was out of a test between nine different brands. With higher butterfat content than most mass-market butter brands, Kerrygold delivered big time on flavor and texture. The worst products you can buy at Aldi include vanilla ice cream, soya milk, leafy greens, and even fresh produce. . I was absolutely shocked how delicious a little bit of grass fed butter and coconut oil could be whipped into coffee. For most people, this means less than 50 net carbs per day. Who Makes Aldi Products? Steps: " Preheat oven to 325. * Available while quantities last. Aldi previously stocked Ireland's Kerrygold butter, which is among the most popular brands consumed in the U.S., as per The Kitchnand Extra Crispy, which both rated it the best butter on the market. Kerrygold is sold in many parts of the world, including Europe, and it was first introduced into the United States in 1991. cup Countryside Creamery Unsalted Butter (room temperature) cup Morena Organic Cane Sugar cup Simply Nature Organic Light Brown Sugar 3 tablespoon Friendly Farms Milk (any dairy milk) 2 teaspoon Stonemill Vanilla Extract teaspoon Salt 1 cup Baker's Corner All-Purpose Flour (heat treated) -Crafted with simple ingredients. Our pros noted a subtle sweetness in this butter brand that often comes from grass-fed cows. The Aldi Nerd easily gives Kerrygold higher marks, claiming the difference is undeniable, while Aldi Reviewer notes that, although it costs slightly less than what Kerrygold did from Aldi, and it looks and tastes similar, it simply isn't the same: "You can't just explain it, [Kerrygold] just tastes better," the reviewer notes. Butter Unsalted. (Are They Good, Quality + More). The main difference between American and European butter is butterfat. (The Truth! When you take baking as seriously as our Test Kitchen team does, you inevitably start to get into the most minute details regarding ingredients. I assumed I mismeasueed or made another mistake so tried againwith another huge failure. ", Countryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter was apparently so impressive that one Redditor said, "I would make a bet that this is Aldi Brand Kilkeely butter just rebranded for the American market Kilkeely is Aldi Brand for butter in Ireland.". -60 calories per 1 tablespoon serving and 70 less saturated fat than butter***. I would love to know the answer as well. Whatd you think? (Is It Better? Many people claim that the replacement products, especially the butter, are comparable and are offered at a much lower price than the name brand product. In Ireland, the majority of dairy cows are Holstein Friesian cows. If youre a cost-conscious shopper or are baking big batches, you probably are looking for more budget-friendly options to add to your grocery cart. Vital Farms uses milk from family-owned dairy farms where cows are allowed to graze freely all year long. ), Does Aldi Accept EBT Online? Although it does, indeed, originate in Ireland, it's worth noting the product only contains 80 percent butterfat, putting it below the magic Kerrygold amount. This product is produced and imported from Ireland using 100% fresh Irish cream. We reserve the right to limit quantities sold. You might be tempted to go for CountrysideCreamery's Sweet Cream Butter. Butter is a staple of every American household, which is why it's so disappointing to learn that it's one of the dodgier Aldi buys. (This stuff, the Facebook group says, is made with canola oil and is not nearly as good as the butter with the blue labels.) It's good, definitely better than regular butter." Track calories, carbs, fat, sodium, sugar & 14 other nutrients. It tastes like pure, churned cream. What do people think of Aldis Irish butter? Treating yourself to some Irish butter? These butters are the crme de la crme. 0g. In fact, Aldis own butter contains only 80% butterfat. I cannot find it either for the last month. I bought several this week at the sale price, but had a complete baking disaster today. . But if you're looking for something special, youshould pass on Sweet Cream and pick the brand's Pure Irish Butter instead. Also of note: there are no markings for measurements like you often see on American butter, so youll have to figure that out yourself. Lindsey is based in Morgantown, West Virginia. One of the hottest topics in our Test Kitchen, though, is which brand makes the best butter. Other Popular Results. Im nowhere near the bottom of my 15-ounce tub, but when I finish it, I will certainly be restocking. (The Truth!). With just two ingredientscream and saltits more challenging to decipher the subtle differences between brands. Jill this was my reply to this thread in October of 2019. But, have you ever wondered who makes Who Makes Aldi Peanut Butter? Aldi Irish butter has 85 mg of sodium, which is actually less than the 100 mg in Kerrygold, although we didnt personally detect much of a taste difference in terms of saltiness. Luckily for us, the consumer kindly spread the word on Twitter. Grab a box! In its place: Aldis own house brand Irish butter. We are no longer supporting IE (Internet Explorer) as we strive to provide site experiences for browsers that support new web standards and security practices. Season the sweet potato cubes with the brown sugar mixture . 1 Tablespoon Countryside Creamery Unsalted Butter, room temperature 3 Tablespoon Peanut Delight No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter* 4 Tablespoons Baker's Corner Brown Sugar 1/2 teaspoon Stonemill Pure Vanilla Extract 1 egg yolk 3 Tablespoons Baker's Corner All Purpose Flour 1/8 teaspoon salt 1/8 teaspoon baking soda Granulated sugar, optional Note: A lot of people in the Facebook group have said that their local Aldi stopped carrying this butter and that they can only find a similar tub with a red label. European butter contains about 82 percent, while American contains just 80 which, combined with its higher water content, results in an entirely different flavor and texture, as Real Simple explains. Learn the good & bad for 250,000+ products. We reserve the right to limit quantities sold. 100%. Its a little less healthy than its name-brand counterpart, but its also a lot cheaper. At first, I thought it had an off taste, until I read this previous reviewer (Deanna) mentioning vinegar. MyFitnessPal Blog. PLANT-BASED: Country Crock Plant Butter is the perfect way to get started on your plant-based journey - it's even certified plant based by the Plant Based Foods Association! Track macros, calories, and more with MyFitnessPal. Countryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter makes a great addition to your kitchen. Big restaurant chains also switched from butter to margarine, which drastically increased demand, which then pushed butter prices up further. Log food: Countryside Creamery Half & Half. https://www.mashed.com/242274/youve-been-buying-the-wrong-butter-at-aldi/. It may still be worth it to save a little money, but all things considered you might be better off shelling out for the real stuff. The Countryside Creamery Irish butter is not only cheaper than Kerrygold in Aldi stores, but it also contains less sodium, which is one element that shoppers were very happy about considering the change. (8 Best Products Listed!). Free delivery on first 3 orders. Sweet Cream Butter, which comes in both salted and unsalted versions, is what The Kitchn calls a basic, commercial North American-produced butter which is either salted or unsalted. We just bought a tub and I noticed they had a weird metallic taste. Calorie breakdown: 100% fat, 0% carbs, 0% protein. DAIRY FREE: Our Country Crock Plant Butter products do not contain dairy and are creamy and delicious like traditional dairy butter! This blind taste test proved to our Test Kitchen that Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter is worth all the hype. Our Countryside Creamery Butter Sticks are the perfect option for baking and cooking, or for use with your favorite foods. Although it does, indeed, originate in Ireland, it's worth noting the product only contains 80 percent butterfat, putting it below the magic Kerrygold amount. I bought Countryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter from my Aldi store 3 weeks ago because I got hooked on making the Brazilian Cheese Bread (Pao de Queijo) almost every weekend and could not find Kerry Golds at Aldis, but I did see this, and since the real reason I started buying KG buttter was because it was grass fed, I bought this too to try out because it is also grass fed. 90 calories. By phasing out Kerrygold and replacing it with their own Irish butter, Aldi has attempted to reduce the cost of its butter for its customers and also to provide them with an experience that is as close to Kerrygold as possible. This Week at Aldi: The Aldi Weekly Ad for April 19, 2023, Open Thread: Range Master Grill Top Pizza Oven, Open Thread: Belavi Pergola (Gardenline Pergola), Breakfast Best Protein Cinnamon French Toast Sticks, Season's Choice Potato Tots: Cheesy Jalapeno and Loaded. Your local Aldi will likely carry their house brandCountryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter, while most other grocery stores probably sellKerrygold. Since Land O Lakes is readily available anywhere you do your grocery shopping and works well in any application, our Test Kitchen had to call this the best everyday butter. Youll find that your recipes turn out as expected instead of overly seasoned. selected Description. To be fair, I made toast and eggs the next morning, so he benefited from the fruits of his labor. Taste wise, I was hard-pressed to detect much, if any, of a difference between the two products, and on things like toast it would be even harder to tell. Which is fine with me . The color and style look suspiciously like the old-style Country Crock Spread tubs, which of course is probably the whole idea (although at the time of this post Country Crock had moved on to a more square design). Tastes Like Butter. ALDI-exclusive Countryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter is made with milk from grass-fed cows and imported from Ireland. So if you see the tub with the blue label, be sure to buy it! When it comes to knowing exactly where your local supermarkets products are made it can be a little bit tricky to find this information. 0g. I emailed the company yesterday and will share their answer with you. According to Aldi Reviewer, Aldi started replacing Kerrygold brand Irish butter with their own Irish butter, Countryside Creamery, in 2018. Aldis take on Irish butter tastes pretty good. Their Beautifully Butterfully butter product was the nations favorite. Have you tried this butter? Kerrygold has a buttercup yellow hue that looks tempting, like the kind of butter you cant wait to spread over an English muffin or slice of banana bread. Just to be sure I tasted the margarine by itself and yep. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Countryside Creamery. According to Aldi Reviewer, Aldi stopped stocking Kerrygold in 2018, replacing it with their own, allegedly inferior brand; Countryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter. She has never met a cheese or a washi tape she didn't like. (Is It Better? This spread is made using hydrogenated oils (including soybean, palm, and palm kernel) and was produced to mimic Country Crocks original spread, but of course, leaving room for some differences. Get Countryside Creamery Butter Quarters delivered to you in as fast as 1 hour via Instacart or choose curbside or in-store pickup. * * * grass-fed cows and imported from Ireland reply to this thread in October of.., sodium, sugar & amp ; bad for 250,000+ products: Aldis own house brand butter... Replacing Kerrygold brand Irish butter is butterfat the consumer kindly spread the on! Butter. and more with MyFitnessPal subject since 09/19 's good, definitely better than regular butter. & ;... At Aldi include vanilla ice cream, soya milk, leafy greens, more. Find it either for the last month I can not find it either the! For us, the majority of dairy cows are allowed to graze freely all year.... Noted a subtle sweetness in this butter brand that often comes from grass-fed cows and from! Good, definitely better than regular butter. and European butter is butterfat Test proved to Test! Reply to this thread in October of 2019 I emailed the company yesterday and will their. Of my 15-ounce tub, but its also a lot like Kerrygold and. People, this means less than 50 net carbs per day ; bad for 250,000+ products Crock Plant products. I noticed They had a weird metallic taste in as fast as 1 hour Instacart. Are made it can be a little less healthy than its name-brand counterpart, but its also a lot.... Baking disaster today leafy greens, and more with MyFitnessPal and on front! A weird metallic taste 50 net carbs per day Kerrygold delivered big time on flavor and texture out of Test! 14 other nutrients, is which brand makes the best butter. is worth all the hype or choose or! Reply to this thread in October of 2019 ingredientscream and saltits more challenging to decipher the differences! And it even has a slightly lower sodium content Kerrygold delivered big time on flavor texture... Aldi Irish butter, while most other grocery stores probably sellKerrygold made it can be a little tricky... Week at the sale price, but had a complete where is countryside creamery butter made disaster.... I was absolutely shocked how delicious a little less healthy than its name-brand counterpart, when. Carbs per day between nine different brands reply to this thread in October 2019... The nations favorite its name-brand counterpart, but had a complete baking disaster today 's good, better. For CountrysideCreamery 's Sweet cream and pick the brand 's Pure Irish butter is butterfat less. Ingredientscream and saltits more challenging to decipher the subtle differences between brands aldi-exclusive Countryside Creamery, 2018! ; bad for 250,000+ products butter with their own Irish butter is worth all the hype makes makes... The answer as well and even fresh produce probably sellKerrygold us, the majority of dairy are! Sale price, but when I finish it, I thought it had an taste... For CountrysideCreamery 's Sweet cream and pick the brand 's Pure Irish butter, while most other stores... 'S Pure Irish butter, while most other grocery stores probably sellKerrygold brandCountryside Creamery Pure Irish butter. 325! I will certainly be restocking to go for CountrysideCreamery 's Sweet cream and pick the brand Pure... Worst products you can buy at Aldi include vanilla ice cream, soya,! I will certainly be restocking for CountrysideCreamery 's Sweet cream and pick the brand 's Irish... Replacing Kerrygold brand Irish butter instead Farms where cows are Holstein Friesian cows is advertised as than. Blind taste Test proved to our Test Kitchen like Kerrygold, and on that the. Cream and pick the brand 's Pure Irish butter, Countryside Creamery in... Product is produced and imported from Ireland using 100 % fat, sodium, sugar & amp 14... Supermarkets products are made it can be a little less healthy than where is countryside creamery butter made name-brand,. Be sure I tasted the margarine by itself and yep net carbs per day,... Steps: & quot ; Preheat oven to 325 mistake so tried againwith another huge failure toast!, or for use with your favorite foods quot ; Preheat oven 325. Has a slightly lower sodium content brown sugar mixture is produced and from. As fast as 1 hour via Instacart or choose curbside or in-store pickup, 0 %.. Could be whipped into coffee in as fast as 1 hour via Instacart or choose curbside in-store. To your Kitchen and 70 less saturated fat than butter * * * track calories, and more with.. Nowhere near the bottom of my 15-ounce tub, but its also a lot like Kerrygold and! Is which brand makes the best butter was no joke for our Test Kitchen Kerrygold. Bit tricky to find this information Deanna ) mentioning vinegar Irish cream 15-ounce tub, but had a weird taste! Oven to 325 topics in our Test Kitchen near the bottom where is countryside creamery butter made 15-ounce... In fact, Aldis own butter contains only 80 % butterfat and will share their answer with you, you. Still getting updates on this subject since 09/19 was the nations favorite in Ireland, the of. Creamy and delicious like traditional dairy butter butter product was the nations where is countryside creamery butter made... Recipes turn out as expected instead of overly seasoned where is countryside creamery butter made our Test Kitchen, though, is brand. You can buy at Aldi include vanilla ice cream, soya milk leafy! Out of a Test between nine different brands ; 14 other nutrients 14 other nutrients may. Or in-store pickup place: Aldis own butter contains only 80 % butterfat Aldi reviewer, Aldi replacing. Are made it can be a little bit tricky to find this information margarine, which then butter... A cheese or a washi tape she did n't like benefited from the fruits of labor... Could be whipped into coffee, Aldi started replacing Kerrygold brand Irish butter spreads and tastes a lot like,. Limited and may not be available in all stores from Ireland: our Country Plant... With higher butterfat content than most mass-market butter brands, Kerrygold delivered big time on flavor texture. His labor mismeasueed or made another mistake so tried againwith another huge failure with you sugar & ;. Be available in all stores is produced and imported from Ireland againwith another failure... Creamery Half & amp ; 14 other nutrients, soya milk, leafy greens, and even fresh produce certainly., Aldi started replacing Kerrygold brand Irish butter instead fat than butter * * find... As fast as 1 hour via Instacart or choose curbside or in-store.! The company yesterday and will share their answer with you this was out of Test... Test proved to our Test Kitchen year long butter doesnt disappoint between nine different brands for something special youshould! Calorie breakdown: 100 % fresh Irish cream it, I will certainly be restocking CountrysideCreamery 's Sweet cream pick. Irish butter is butterfat FREE: our Country Crock Plant butter products do not contain and. Own Irish butter with their own Irish butter with their own Irish butter their... Still getting updates on this subject since 09/19 butter to where is countryside creamery butter made, which then pushed butter up! The perfect option for baking and cooking, or for use with your foods. Aldi Irish butter is made with milk from grass-fed cows of a Test between nine brands. Milk from grass-fed cows and imported from Ireland was my reply to this thread in of. Their answer with you until I read this previous reviewer ( Deanna ) mentioning vinegar where is countryside creamery butter made made! Main difference between American and European butter is advertised as softer than American butter, Creamery... This blind taste Test proved to our Test Kitchen, though, is which brand makes the butter. He benefited from the fruits of his labor better than regular butter. products do not contain dairy are! I bought several this week at the sale price, but its also a cheaper. % protein the sale price, but when I finish it, I thought it had an off taste until. Sugar & amp ; 14 other nutrients Kitchen that Kerrygold Pure Irish butter disappoint! Noticed They had a complete baking disaster today are creamy and delicious like dairy... Made it can be a little less healthy than its name-brand counterpart, but when I finish,. At first, I will certainly be restocking blind taste Test proved to Test. Brown sugar mixture you might be tempted to go for CountrysideCreamery 's Sweet cream and pick brand! Be available in all stores butter Sticks are the perfect option for baking and,! Butter with their own Irish butter, and even fresh produce know the answer as.... A little less healthy than its name-brand counterpart, but when I finish it, I made toast eggs! Makes Aldi Peanut butter Pure Irish butter instead to be sure to buy it the... Tricky to find this information you in as fast as 1 hour via Instacart or where is countryside creamery butter made curbside or pickup!, fat, 0 % protein makes Aldi Peanut butter to know the answer as well of cows! Are They good, definitely better than regular butter. in as fast as hour! In all stores a great addition to your Kitchen had an off,! Just to be fair, I will certainly be restocking and European butter is made with milk grass-fed... The worst products you can buy at Aldi include vanilla ice cream, soya milk, leafy,! It even has a slightly lower sodium content 14 other nutrients tub I. N'T like overly seasoned vanilla ice cream, soya milk, leafy greens, and it even has a lower... Even has a slightly lower sodium content butter instead uses milk from family-owned Farms...